Comparisons of shapes can be quantified somewhat- that's why I can see the more than coincidental similarities from the rip off concept. The larger side intakes and longer tail on the production version were a by product of them switching to twin turbo packaging and longitudinal layout... Not stylistic exercises.
The shapes have been quantified in blueprint/orthogonal form as shown and it clearly shows the NSX and R8 bears little resemblance in geometry.
The length of the car was elongated to suit the new layout. That has nothing to do with extending the rear/spoiler and larger side intakes were inevitable actually. Michelle claimed the styling choice of the spoiler to coincide with aerodynamics testing....
But the longer tail/spoiler lends to losing the illusion of the stubby-ness or that snub look.
Let's talk about art for a second tho since I went back and re-read your R8 comments and how objects makes different people feel certain ways. Yes, art has almost no logic and it's ultimately up to the spectator and how he/she feels about the work. However, let's introduce some logic into your associations. You claim the new NSX is copying/mimicing the R8 because of the headlight design and almost vertical side intake.
-Wouldn't the first NSX be copying the C4 vette's C pillar? As the C4 debuted in 1984, a full 5 years before we saw the NSX surface.
-The first gen also has pop headlights like many other sports cars, so it's copying that too?
-The Gallardo, R8 and then 12C actually mimics the NSX's unique long side intake from door to rear quarter panel, but no one claims they are copying the NSX.
-The Evora and MP4-12C mimics the NSX's unique integrated spoiler tail, but no one really claims they are copying the NSX.
-Then others can argue that the NSX's rear tail is a conservative version of the F40's tail, but that's a long shot.
-The 12C's side intake bears more resemblance with the R8 because of the high contrast 2 tone inserts, but no one seems to be making that association eh?
The R8 is the closest in virtue to what the NSX was when it first come out and I honestly think that's why the new NSX is being compared to the R8. Leap-Frog Effect as the first NSX influenced the R8 a lot.
By the rules of art, you can claim whatever you want about your own feelings, but by logic, you can't target a very particular detail and say because of that one detail of similarity, that they are very similar or copies. Now, if they were laid out the same way in a sense of blueprint style thinking, then it would be a clear copy. Like a hotel stealing floorplans from another competitor's hotel.
This is why the shape or proportions are important. The Corvette and NSX have a lot in common in details, but one is FR and the other MR, so they have different profiles/shapes/layout and most car people recognize that. The R8 while mid-engine, mostly resembles a FR car with it's bulbous stance. One can clearly tell the new NSX is mid-engine as it was never as bulbous as the R8 and now ever more so refined to be sharper. I agree that the taller flying buttress intake and headlight hang is reminiscent of the R8, but so are a lot of details on any cars. You can say the same for music, food, movies, etc.
I just wanted to put my 2 cents in on details since I overlooked it the first time.
- - - Updated - - -
vf2ss, I can't wait for people to start modding the new NSX and see what they actually come up with because those chops look very enticing.