Love the Sport too, and want it to grow, however it must be fair to all
Bram
Totally.
Love the Sport too, and want it to grow, however it must be fair to all
Bram
After having had some time to reflect. In retrospect the red flag would have been the better call.The race director made a really bad call - he should have red-flagged the Latifi incident (as the car was on track and would require a lot of intervention by marshals on-track to clear the damaged car and debris) , allowing for a 5 lap sprint finish from a standing start.
As he didn't red-flag and chose the safety car option, he should have followed the rules fully - either let all the lapped cars though (if there was time), or if not, the safety car should have come in once the track was clear of debris and marshals, and the race itself restarts with a rolling start the lap after the safety car has returned to the pits, after communicating to all teams what was gong to happen.
Basically the race director cherry picked some bits of the rules, but didn't follow the established procedure. It was almost as if he was trying to achieve a particular outcome...
With the expected "new era" of the 2022 season and beyond. Who's to say this isn't Lewis' last chance. I'm reminded of Vettel, Alonso, Kimi. In many ways their situations are different but who knows how the teams will stack up next year.You are so correct with the actions of the Racing Director, however at the end of the day he made a series of bad calls and handed the WC to Mad Max....Lewis have 7 WC, so he'll have to wait for 8, 9, 10 before he retire.
I believe Merc will withdraw it's appeal to the FIA Courts, as they already have 8 Constructors Championships and Lewis have 7 WC...so let RB and Mad Max have this one curtesy of Michael Masi. Masi, needs to be replaced by the FIA....he is terrible.
Bram
I think the team principals should be heavily fined for trying to tell Masi what stuff he needs to do. Part of it is Masi's fault for not being Whiting.how does everyone here feel about having the open mic from massi to the teams?
I'm not going to bet against MERC in 2022 with all the changes being introduce for next year.
Bram
I remember how successful Ferrari was when there were no limits to testing. They had the deepest pockets, now the money is spent on the wind tunnel, the computer simulators, and the people who do all the computer models.
If the engineering piece is neutered too much, F1 will lose fans like me. The nerdy tech is half the reason I watch it. Spec series (like Indy) is just not fun for me. I love the variation in hardware.F1 is an arms race and always will be. That said, I think they should cut the engineering staff allocation by at least 50% and strictly limit testing. Just seeing the size of the RB crowd at Milton Keynes to welcome Max tells me there F1 has gotten way too complex and expensive. But, if you clamp them down too much you end up with Nascar- basically the same car for all teams which is boring. Part of the attraction of F1 is to see how teams choose to attack the problem of the Formula, but this also means some will choose wisely (Mercedes, RB) and others poorly (Alpine). Meanwhile, the smaller teams can't employ the 2,000 engineers to make a good choice either way...
F1 is an arms race and always will be. That said, I think they should cut the engineering staff allocation by at least 50% and strictly limit testing. Just seeing the size of the RB crowd at Milton Keynes to welcome Max tells me there F1 has gotten way too complex and expensive. But, if you clamp them down too much you end up with Nascar- basically the same car for all teams which is boring. Part of the attraction of F1 is to see how teams choose to attack the problem of the Formula, but this also means some will choose wisely (Mercedes, RB) and others poorly (Alpine). Meanwhile, the smaller teams can't employ the 2,000 engineers to make a good choice either way...
If the engineering piece is neutered too much, F1 will lose fans like me. The nerdy tech is half the reason I watch it. Spec series (like Indy) is just not fun for me. I love the variation in hardware.
As I’m driving along the San Diego bay I think about America’s Cup yachts.
which are now hydrofoils...
I believe that's why the costs caps are there along with the limited testing time, control tires, etc.I hear you and love the nerdy bits too, but where does it stop? I bet McLaren has 3 PhD engineers who all they do is design the aerodynamics of the nuts that bolt the front winglets to the wing. I mean, they were using the vortex from the squish of the tire rubber to help with downforce.
I think the team principals should be heavily fined for trying to tell Masi what stuff he needs to do. Part of it is Masi's fault for not being Whiting.
There was a clip of Toto giving Masi directions. That was BS. Christian is guilty of that too. They should be fined heavily for that behavior.
I think the team principals should be heavily fined for trying to tell Masi what stuff he needs to do. Part of it is Masi's fault for not being Whiting.
There was a clip of Toto giving Masi directions. That was BS. Christian is guilty of that too. They should be fined heavily for that behavior.
Have you ever seen or heard coaches in football, baseball, basketball, soccer, etc plead with and tell referees what to do?
FIA to investigate the Abu Dhabi 2021 GP....
The FIA, in a statement issued on Wednesday evening, have recognised the fall-out from events in Abu Dhabi is “tarnishing the image of the championship” – and have said they will study what happened “with all relevant parties”, as proposed by President Jean Todt who is about to exit his post following the maximum 12 years in office.
The statement read in full: “On Sunday, another FIA F1 World Championship season of competitive excellence concluded, and the credit goes to the participating drivers and teams. The FIA congratulates all of them for their performances in this year. It was a hard fight, and the best competition was displayed at each grand prix.
“The world watched every race with great anticipation, knowing in the end there could only be one winner. In this respect, many praised Max Verstappen for his victory, and Lewis Hamilton for his remarkable performance and sportsmanship after the closing event of the season.
“The 2021 FIA Formula 1 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix has prompted a large number of reactions from the F1 community and from motorsport in general, as well as in the public. The FIA’s primary responsibility at any event is to ensure the safety of everyone involved and the integrity of the sport.
“The circumstances surrounding the use of the Safety Car following the incident of driver Nicholas Latifi, and the related communications between the FIA Race Direction team and the Formula 1 teams, have notably generated significant misunderstanding and reactions from Formula 1 teams, drivers and fans – an argument that is currently tarnishing the image of the Championship and the due celebration of the first Drivers’ World Championship title won by Max Verstappen and the eighth consecutive Constructors’ World Championship title won by Mercedes.
“Following the presentation of a report regarding the sequence of events that took place following the incident on lap 53 of the grand prix and in a constant drive for improvement, the FIA President proposed to the World Motor Sport Council that a detailed analysis and clarification exercise for the future with all relevant parties will now take place.
“This matter will be discussed and addressed with all the teams and drivers to draw any lessons from this situation and clarity to be provided to the participants, media and fans about the current regulations to preserve the competitive nature of our sport while ensuring the safety of the drivers and officials
“It is not only Formula 1 that may benefit from this analysis but also more generally all the other FIA circuit championships.
“Following that presentation and an extensive discussion, the World Council has decided to unanimously support the President’s proposal.
“The FIA will therefore do its utmost to have this in motion within the Formula 1 governance and will propose to the Formula 1 Commission to give a clear mandate for study and proposal to the Sporting Advisory Committee, with the support of Formula 1 drivers, so any identified meaningful feedback and conclusions be made before the beginning of the 2022 season.”
which are now hydrofoils...
As I’m driving along the San Diego bay I think about America’s Cup yachts.
What a bunch of Jive Talking - the people who wrote this are clearly better suited to politics than sport
Yep.
There is a line between thinking smarter, and turning the sport into a pure science experiment.
Exactly my point. In "professional" sports they get a fine or a technical foul or some type of penalty for going over the line. What is the line in F1.. not sure but they both crossed it in my opinion.Have you ever seen or heard coaches in football, baseball, basketball, soccer, etc plead with and tell referees what to do?
But, the current 1.6 still sounds like a wet fart and takes away from the entertainment factor. I kind of wish they would keep the 1.6 but ditch the hybrid (we have Formula E now to cater to that segment) and run a twin turbo at about 4 bar using E85 or a similar biofuel for the eco street cred.
This is a great way to put it. I think the line is different for different fans, which is part of the problem. Too much control by the FIA and you get Nascar or IROC, where it is truly a driver's series since all the cars are nearly identical. Too little control and the major teams with deep corporate pockets run wild and simply outspend all of the other teams (see my comment about the three engineers dedicated to aero on a nut LOL) so that it becomes a really, really expensive version of a university engineering department running RC cars around a track. And, the one with the most money always wins. Always. Wins. The drivers are just a cog in the machine and simply have to drive to a mistake-free pre-determined plan that was validated after 10,000 virtual laps on the simulators.
Obviously, the answer is somewhere in the middle, but right now I think we are too far on the "science experiment" end of the spectrum. I'm hopeful the 2022 changes will address some of this. I'm happy to see that RB got the engines to freeze until 2025, which will push down costs. But, the current 1.6 still sounds like a wet fart and takes away from the entertainment factor. I kind of wish they would keep the 1.6 but ditch the hybrid (we have Formula E now to cater to that segment) and run a twin turbo at about 4 bar using E85 or a similar biofuel for the eco street cred.