It's special enough to win comparison tests at Motor Trend:
Because it's priced well in a small number of FR coupes available right now. Otherwise it's a generic looking coupe with ok interior - still very unrefined. It is receiving applause because the competition is weak. There is not much for it to compete with, so it's not hard to win. If you would have thrown a used fine example of 90s Japanese sports cars, then the Genesis would still lose all day.
Take the 90s 300ZX. It had a classic design and a very special engine. The twin turbo model had an engine that no other Nissan shared. The Rx7, special chassis and engine. The NSX, same story. All three of these cars had engines and bodies specially designed for that car and did not share it with other cars on the lineup. This is the special that I am talking about. The passion to take a chance and dedicate to a pure idea.
The Genesis shares its engine with the whole Hyundai and KIA lineup. The KIA Optima IMO draws more attention than the coupe when both are present. Perhaps the next iteration will yield a better design but again, I bet the engine is still nothing special for it to be considered a pure or even dedicated sports car.
Well you are incorrect. I would, and there are a number of NSX owners here that own hyundais and Kia's.
Then why don't you own one? Why are both of your Hondas not gone and replaced with Hyundais? I noticed you have been objective in many arguments to be fair, but I just think you are just bored and like to debate :tongue: Deep down, you are still lumped in with us. Praise the GTR, but won't buy one. Bag on the new NSX, but I bet you might still buy one lol
Nothing is easy these days for a manufacturer. They have to meet fuel economy standards, emissions standards, reliability standards, driveability standards. You have to do well in all those areas. To call its "cheap and easy" because it has a turbo is just silly. Tell that to BMW. Or McLaren.
No, I am not just simply bagging on a turbo or have anything against them. You misunderstand me. I am talking about the reasons to use one and how it is executed. The 335i is monster but among the sea of 3 series coupes, it still a 3 series. Instead of BMW competing with the rest of 3.5 V6s, they said let's sacrifice reliability and use turbos. Ferrari's 458 uses no turbos and many hold the 458 over the MP4-12c. Anyways, what at I am saying is that it is not unheard of these days for a 4 cylinder to make 280 hp from a turbo when Nissan, Mitsubishi, Toyota, and Subaru have been doing so for almost two decades! There is nothing special about the generic Genesis so far. It follows a very safe and proven formula and that is one of the reasons why Hyundai is not "passionate". If the Genesis were priced at a 370Z price, then I bet we would not be having this discussion.
Look I am not saying Hyundai has reached the pinnacle of engineering, but so far on this thread I've gotten all these reasons that they "suck" and none hold very much water. They have weak points, but no one is bringing these up. Talking about passion or their CEO or saying they are cheap junk and they only sell because the economy is bad like Vance likes to say... These are not factual. They are just opinion.
Truth is if you look at FACTS... that is, reliability numbers, resale value, quality of parts, efficiency, sales figures, etc... Hyundai is a healthy, growing company on an upswing, and Honda has been on a downswing. I have no personal dog in this fight, I am just pointing out basic facts. You guys are talking in a manner like we are comparing Hyundai to Porsche or something when fact is Honda has no sports cars, no great designs of any sort. You guys praise Honda in the first half of the paragraph for being dynamic and well engineered and based in F1 (which is all in the past), then in the second half excuse their lame and boring designs by saying they have to appeal to the mass market, compete with camry's, etc.
So which is it? They can't be both. If they are an exciting company, where are the sports cars and the exciting designs? If they are a ho-hum mass market company, then why are you guys harsh on Hyundai for appealing to the masses and saying their image sucks?
I never said Hyundai sucked. Read what I said about it being unfair to glance over them. My eyes are on them and watching carefully. Don't lump me in with everyone, even if they have valid arguments amongst their diehard loyalty. I never said Hyundai/KIA are incapable of making a special sports car. I am saying they probably can, but they are not going to anytime soon because they are too busy trying to sell lots of cars to the mass public and NOT enthusiasts. This is completely against why we like our cars. This is also why they have yet to surpass Honda , Toyota or even Nissan.
Honda has the pedigree and history with a proven track record for sales and racing. Hyundai had a meteoric rise based on Sales and has no racing history yet. You bash on Honda but praise Nissan because they have a GTR? Nissan's 370Z and 350Z is garbage. Mazda's Miata is anemic. Toyota just released a sports coupe and they had to rely on Subaru to make one after apparently dumping Yamaha. It also is nothing special or awe-inspiring. All of Japan is staggered right now, even though they all have brought something special to the table before. You can have both. There are cash cow cars and then there are sports cars that represent the spirit of the company. These are the cars that push the edge of engineering and design even though they probably will only sell at very low volumes.
Nobody is making excuses for Honda, but they have enough time to listen to the clamor and adjust/adapt. Just as Hyundai still requires more time to atleast reach a higher level of refinement, Honda has time to bounce back. If they don't, then it would ultimately mean the fall of Honda, but I don't see that happening over night or over a decade. This is the first time in a long time that Honda has faltered. They were the last ones in Japan to do so. Toyota, Nissan and Mazda took their dive way before the economy struggled. Mitsubishi is on the brink of withdrawal and Subaru... when did they really matter with their niche market?
I still have hope Honda will reclaim their stride, but if they don't I still won't jump to Hyundai just yet even if the rest of Japan are still sunk. I have nothing against them and hope that they do evolve, but on an enthusiast level, they don't really offer much right now. I am still waiting for Hyundai to prove themselves. Swooping in with bread that is easily obtainable among a group of starving people does not impress me. This is what the Genesis and FR-S/BR-Z are capitalizing on. I see pass the initial satisfaction one feels when first biting into any available food after starvation. It is still mediocre bread.