What this discussion seems to confirm is my previously-stated view that there are many different ways to lose weight, and you need to choose the one that works
for you. Six small meals, one meal, no meals, breakfast eating, nighttime eating, etc - lots of different approaches. I've tried most of them, and what works
for me is pretty similar to what Stick-e-rice describes (maybe it's because I love Thai food - my freezer is stocked with tom kha gai from one of our local places
). I realize that what I am doing - lots of non-nutritional liquids*, lots of skipped meals, eating only in the early evening - may not be theoretically optimal, but on a practical level, it works for me. If you use a different approach and it works for you, that's great too.
clr1024 said:
As for most people over eating, people usually over eat because there is a 10 to 15 minute delay between your stomach telling your brain its full/satiated at which point you stop eating, because of the delay you have actually overeaten.
Actually, I think most people overeat - at least, I do (or did) - more so because we are accustomed to eating until we are full/satiated. The 2000-2500 calorie daily intake that maintains weight never makes me feel full/satiated. Not after 10-15 minutes, not with a glass of water before the meal. Never. I've realized I need to decide to stop eating when I have eaten a proper amount, not continuing until my body tells me to stop. An occasional splurge meal may be an exception, but I'm realizing that for me, the idea of leaving the dinner table every day feeling full is something I need to give up.
* I drink 3-4 cans of diet soda a day, and have done so for my entire adult life, even when I have not been watching my weight. However, on days when I skip
all meals - and there are some (like I said, do what works
for you) - I try to drink a nutritional weight-control shake. As previously mentioned, beware a lot of these products, as many of them are labeled "low calorie" but have a lot of carbs, and others are labeled "low carb" but have a lot of calories. I prefer the "AdvantEdge Carb Control" shake made by
EAS, which has 15 g of protein, but only 100 calories and only 1 g of impact carbs (2 g of carbs but 1 of which is fiber).