This is the one quote I want to argue. You live in Southern California and you say you can't drive "spirted" where you live? Well, California has more road tracks than any other state I have been to. If you had a manual nsx you could actually take to a HPDE and track it and see just how good of a car it is. 90% of the people on prime don't realize how good their car is since they never take it to its limits. THAT is my problem with an automatic. Once you get one you have already predetermined how much fun you will have with your car. There is nothing wrong with taking your car to the track once in awhile. People act like that is a sin when in fact it should be a requirement for our cars. These cars weren't meant to drive doctors to and from work. They were meant to run at high revs push high G forces on turns.
So to the original poster, I say it is just better in the long run to get the manual. Lots of people get Autos for one reason or another but you will get more enjoyment from the car by banging thru the gears. Come to NSXPO and you will see.
I wanted to restart this thread again in that I found out a few things about my 95 automatic when I participated in the HPDE at Spring Mountain Motor Ranch at NSXPO 2010.
First, my automatic did just fine on the track. I was in the novice group and after a few sessions and after learning the track and lines, my car did it’s fare share of passing of NA1’s and NA2’s. In fact, by the second day, nobody passed me. Now granted, driving skill is a factor on the track. However, I have to say that I was surprised at how well my car performed in automatic mode. I did not need to shift into sports mode to be successful on the track.
Second, although I was not able to keep up with the manuals on the long straits (due to less HP) I was able to make up for this on the twisties. However, the manuals (stock) did not leave me in the dust, they only gradually pulled away.
Lastly, on the second day, I developed transmission problems. I lost 3rd gear, and then I lost 1st and 4th, which forced me to stop running. However, even without 3rd gear, I was still passing some cars. My car is currently at Finlay Acura. The initial diagnosis is an electrical defect. The defective part (the name I cannot remember) will take up to five days to obtain. After Finlay replaces that part, they will then be able to determine if there are mechanical problems with the transmission. I’m keeping my fingers crossed that the problem was only electrical.
Conclusion, my automatic did very well against the manuals, however, whether or not the stresses of racing with the auto caused the loss of gears is yet to be determined. I did spin out 3 times during my runs, and my transmission problems did occur after these spin outs. Does anyone have experience with automatic transmission failure due to going backwards on spin outs? I heard this somewhere, but I could not confirm this problem.
NSXPO 2010 and the HPDE was great, and in my opinion autos are not as bad as they are made out to be!
Best,
Mario