BadCarma said:
sahtt, From one standpoint, the cost for decent modifications for the NSX are so expensive, nitrous becomes a great alternative to those that want a stock performing/sounding NSX when they want, and a z06 killer when they need it.
SO you are saying that n20 done correctly is a cheap solution But not a decent modifiction? also you think our X'S are stock? and not modded with I/HE untill we hit the magic button? then its a zo6 killer.
Never said anything to suggest nitrous wasn't a 'decent' modification. Don't waste your time getting defensive, you have no need to. By decent I meant cheaper parts vs highend japenese parts like 2-3k exhausts. It makes absolutely no difference whether your NSX, or any other NSX that is contemplating adding a nitrous system is stock or not regarding the points I made.
BadCarma said:
From another standpoint, the replacement cost for an NSX engine is quite high. 75hp is not worth getting overly concerned about, but at 100hp or above puts enough additional stress on the engine to the point you should not be attempting it if you cannot risk replacing the engine. Done right, it can last many years. If done even slightly incorrectly, you will be out 10 grand overnight.
So correct me here because I want to understand your logic,at 100 hp is it n20 that becomes unsafe or the n20 safe and a risk the S/C also that is making a 100hp? so if the n20 is done right and the S/C WRONG wheres that put us?
I don't fully understand what you are saying but I'll do my best. We can both agree, adding 1000hp by way of nitrous would be detrimental to the NSX engine. 500hp? Probably the same. 300hp? If the engine was completely built, with lower compression, etc., and some very large injectors, it could be safe. On a stock engine? Still detrimental. Where do you draw the line? My logic is from experience. The NSX engine is a fairly high compression n/a setup with 276hp-290hp. The 100 shot will roughly add at least 100bhp, or 33% of the engine's original output. This is the figure I and my collegues typically consider the point in which the additional stress on the engine becomes noteworthy. There is almost no way to determine it scientifically without doing a trial with leakdown and compression tests, if not full blown engine teardowns, to see how much excess wear and tear the nitrous, or any modification, has caused. Bottom line, it would be wise for the individual to do enough research to decide where on his particular setup he should draw the line between 'safe' power and 'potentially hazardous' power. I think that line is around a 100 shot on a stock NSX. It would be very difficult to refute that with any evidence, as saying your particular car did so means very little, but I'm glad for you if that is your case.
Towards the end of this section, I think you were touching on the golden question, how is 100hp from nitrous any different as far as wear and tear and strain on the engine than a SC or turbo charger setup? Well, in fact, it can cause more. The means in which the power is produced is not the same, though similar. This is an excerpt I did not write, so I'll quote it-
"If there isn't enough fuel, and the NO2 is cracked into it's consitiuent parts, you have excess liberated O2. So more than just run lean, the O2 can actually ignite and BURN components of your engine---most notably the pistons. This is why the most sophisticated NO2 systems now utilize WBO2 feedback in the safety loop to disable the NO2 injection of the equation.
Like Jeff points out, first you run lean, and break the pistons, but if you keep in it, and pump that cylinder full of NO2, and it cracks into the separate parts, then that 30%+ Oxygen-Rich Environment will start something burning.
If you are lucky, you break pistons. If you are unlucky, or just plain stoopid, you BURN PARTS...The nature in which N02 produces its power makes it more dangerous than a FI setup, even if both are well coordinated and tuned."
"The real issue then becomes the switching of the NOS on and off. With fuel injectioon it is possible to make a circuit that will switch on and off the NOS based an a mumber of parameters of the engine to make it wery effective for the N/A engine. Switching is KEY in such a system, but I only know of one system that will do that, at least that I would use, and again that is a calculation. Learn you basic BOSCH fuel injection system, then get into the formulas for calculation mixture, Then and ONLY then begin work with NOS. You can always choose to do the seat of the pants setup, but in most cases it will end up in broken pistons."
BadCarma said:
It would be a shame to blow your engine up when you could have had a well set up SC or even turbo kit for much less.
I can get a S/C and correct engine management tuned and set up for much less then 10 grand? including a stand alone ecu and all the dyno time and a wide band logger OR you mean I could get a S/C base unit from COMPTECH and using their state of the art FMS I am way safer then the way I ,we do it with n20 which is BTW the same!. help me learn here,its never to late.what works best on your S/C?
looking forward to your response to ALL the questions answered as I really want to understand how they do the magic they do with a 100 saftey record.
for all you hard core tuners ready to xplain it to me I want to hear from the wise man first on ALL the points then feel free to chime?
Best Regards David
You could get a less aggressive SC system setup for under 10k, especially if you didn't max out the stock fuel injectors. Well under if you do the work yourself and source some of the parts used that don't 'need' be new'er'. What does 'much less' mean to you? I don't know. I'm not going to break down the parts just to 'prove' to you it can be done. I'm not arguing that nitrous isn't cheaper, I'm saying you could quite possibly have a FI system that you can use for the next 5 or 10 years with the money 'risked' by doing a larger nitrous shot. For some cars, a junkyard turbo setup is more than a replacement engine, the NSX is not one of them.
BadCarma said:
Just do your HW as it seems you are and you'll probably be fine.
we will take your thoughts to heart on this matter. BTW whats the differnce between how n20 makes its power and a standard 6 psi S/C and what is the difference in what is done hardware wise to tune the 6 psi COMPTECH unit and N20. Fyi THEY BOTH USE THE SAME TRICKING OF THE STCK ECU to attain A/F. if I add an aem ecu to control my n20 is it safer then the way the comptech unit controls A/F now?
and lastly do you own a supercharger? if so do you understand how it tricks the ecu into proper A/F and if so do you know how a n20 dry kit tricks the ECU? I really want to understand and save my precious motor from a 10 grand slag from a cheap trick setup that is good enough for n20 dry but not as solid as a S/C. btw has ,have ANY comptech blowers slagged a motor due to improper A/F or a turbo for that matter. please take the time to retort as you took the time to disparage and want to know these things so I never injure my motor with a bad S/C or n20 fuel mangement design. and will then dismiss those photos of the S/C comptech car with a whole in the engine block you could STICK your head through.
Their is always so much to learn from the new tuners these days, you are a tuner right? I may be intererested having my car tuned by you so I dont lose its awesome A/F on and off the juice AND I really want to understand how and why my motors compression is so good. and can help me with my COMPTECH S/C with direct port n20 setup I am working on so I have it down pat.
Where to start.. I won't get into too much detail since much of this is a ramblings entrenched with frustrations about SC vs nitrous 'rivalry', or something like that.
You are going way deeper into the matter as far as the hardware of the two systems [SC vs nitrous] and their than I am concerned with. I'm not defending the SC systems specifically for the NSX. I don't care what tuning these packages have, stand alone is better, aem ems is great, less exact ways adjusting fuel pressure etc. is always going to be the cheaper, less efficient way. As far as our comparisons about 'your' nitrous setup using aem vs the SC package using a cheap FRM being more reliable is hard to evaluate, there is not enough information available to me to even give an educated opinion on that.
I do not own a supercharger on a NSX. I've worked on and setup many SC'd cars, including my past s2k. I've also built my turbo 300zx on an engine stand and am fairly familiar with most tuning softwares. The only cars I regularly tune now are ones with K series engines using K-pro. I do not consider myself even an amature tuner, nor ever claimed to be. I also currently have a suzuki bandit 1200cc with a 40+/- shot I use every once in a while at the drag strip, so I've had experience in most automotive fields as far as FI goes. Your loss of composure is unnecessary, especially considering the forum's respect towards your knowledge on the matter. A 'comptech' car [note I never claimed comptech was anything good or bad] that blew up for some reason means nothing to me. Stock cars blow up. FI cars with proper tuning blow up. Cars on nitrous use it regularly for 100k miles. Cars on nitrous blow up on their 2nd bottle. Circumstantial cases are irrelavent to me. So are the individual components of the available SC systems when most can be sold and replaced with different ones without huge expenses or trouble.
I congratulate you on your nitrous knowledge and combination of SC and nitrous power, but everything I've said is at worst, subjective, if not common knowledge.
If I really cared to, I could go into extreme detail to figure out exactly how the true costs of the nitrous system vs FI system compare or differ depending on horsepower goals and amount of use. However, I don't have the time, especially after this post. To start, you could multiply the average nitrous use over the period of a week and see how long it takes to reach a significant cost, say 1k. Eventually, the 'cheaper' nitrous kit would be more expensive than the FI kit on that basis alone, but I ignored that for the duration of this topic.
Like I said from the start, nitrous has its benefits as does FI, but on the NSX platform you need to fully evaluate the cost/benefit analysis of going much over a 100 shot on a NSX. You've got the knowledge and went with it, but it isn't for everyone, nor is FI.