You hit a lot of good points here. You're right, the market is much more competitive now with tons more to cross shop. Right now, Acura as a brand is super bland. They are like the unmotivated version of Lexus. Lexus and Acura both use incredibly outdated tech ie. the same old 2.5L and drivetrain in the new IS250 but Acura takes it to another level. Seriously, a 5-speed auto in the ILX? Atleast Lexus is trying something radical in the aesthetic department. Honda needs to seriously start bringing more than jewel-eye LEDs into their new vehicles. It starts with advanced technology and engineering. If they can deliver a better product, the marque can rebrand on its own. Its much harder to take something lackluster and try convincing the public that its great. Honda is the brand you look to if you want drama-free, reliable and cost effective ownership. It didn't become that way because Honda waved a magic wand. It became that way because thats what owners truly experienced. If Honda wants Acura to be a certain type of brand, they have to make vehicles that deliver an experience that is associated with that type of brand. I hope the NSX is the car that does that but they have a mountain to climb... I'm staying optimistic though, the car so far looks great and has the technology that I'm excited for.
Just take the Civic Type R Turbo motor and put it into the ILX or a new RSX and call it day Acura... That baby NSX/S2000 successor can't come any sooner if rumors continue to prove true.