Well, that depends on what you're looking for. As you're already aware, the F1 GS-D3 was exceptional because it provided pretty good treadlife and excellent rain traction, along with dry performance that was excellent - not quite up there with those extreme performance tires, but pretty darn close. Now that niche in the market is occupied by the Continental ExtremeContact DW, which is available in 215/40-17 and 265/35-18. (Incidentally, for some reason the Tire Rack does not show this tire in 215/40-17, but it is definitely available in that size from other retailers including Discount Tire Direct.) So for your situation, that's what I would recommend.Are those tires listed in your order of preference? I stockpiled a few sets of F1-GSD3s a while back and I am about to mount up my last set of rears. I tend to go through 2 sets of rears for one set of fronts. Now that the GSD3 is extinct, I'm soon going to be looking for its successor for Charlotte. Since you know how much mileage I do and that it rains a lot down here in the summer I'm curious as to which tire you'd recommend. My early inclination is to go with the Star Specs.
For the ultimate in traction, all three of the extreme performance tires I listed in the post you quote are excellent (differences are minor, but if I had to choose only one, it would be the Star Spec). But their downside is that they wear relatively quickly, more so than the ExtremeContact DW or the F1 GS-D3.
HTH