Angus do you have pics of those two different tires on a 10.5" rear wheel? That would help me see what the lower width and higher width would look like.
I hypothetically want to use a 275/35/19 on a 10.5" wide wheel for the rear. Now I know the speedo will be off bc of the higher aspect but I used these on my 9.5" rears before with Falken 452s and did not have any problems with TCS. The 35 series tire gives some more sidewall height so the tire doesn't look so skinny (like a 30 aspect) and I had a beautifully rounded shoulder profile w the 9.5"w. It also helped fill up my fender well bc the Type R suspension leaves the back end a tad high. But, I am worried that it may be too stretched with the extra 1" of width on a 10.5" wheel. Does the sidewall height get reduced with stretched tires? What's the consensus on the best tire size for a 10.5" with a safe offset, would 285/30/19 be better? The tire selection in that size becomes a problem though.
Here's a photo of the sidewall profile I liked (275/35//19), do the Falken 452s run wide or narrow? They didn't have a bead protector though.
275-35-19_NSX_tire_profile by
Nero Tenebre, on Flickr