I LOVE the way you titled your post. "caretaker"-----did you buy it to keep it nice for the next owner (?) or "end user"------did you buy it to ENJOY for yourself (?). Once you answer that question the rest is easy. I bought an '05 12 months ago with only 13,250 miles on the ODO. Obviously the first owner bought it to be a garage queen. Personally I'm glad he kept it nice for me. 12 months later I now have another 11,000 miles on the ODO and I am ENJOYING the car every day. I'm planning to drive it until the wheels fall off, then find another fool who put one in the garage and worshipped it every day while denying himself the pleasure of actually driving it. This car begs to be driven. Answer your own question about caretaker or end user then go for it.