Given the highly competitive process of getting into any graduate school your undergrad will count for or against you. As between a grad of an Unranked college and someone with similar grades in a ranked school "size does matter".
My law school was ranked 25th and the acceptance rate was only 9 percent of applicants. When only 1 out of every 11 get accepted you will need the pedigree to distinguish yourself. I dont know any students in my class who attended any college ranked outside the top 75 in the country and everyone was top 5 percent on the lsats and pretty much top 10 percent in their college class. Medical school is even tougher to get into.
that may be true for your school, but you're misleading him, making it sound like only 1 of 11 who applied to your law school went to law school. Unless they are too cheap, or too stupid, and only apply to your school, i'm reasonably sure the "other 10" of your 11 applied, and a good chunk matriculated, to other schools. So it's more likely 40% or 50% got in somewhere.
Hell.. i applied to 52 med schools. BFD. It's a numbers game, and you have to play to win. I also applied to 25 anesthesiology programs. The only time i applied to 1 program, was when i sent in my app for University of Arizona, because i knew by state law they had to accept me.