To the OP: This should make you feel a lot better about youre car. First realize the best year model color tranny, tire and engine is going to be the one YOU own. That said I found in my search that every OLD car is different, year, mileage, type of mileage, maintenance whatever. I drove everything variation but a NA2 Coupe but I knew I found mine the moment I pulled away and pushed thru 2nd gear, it was just…felt better, more raw than the others, though a all orig 91 with fat fives was a close second. AFAIK the only independent unbiased head to head between a NA1 Targa and a NA 2 Targa was when Everyday Driver reviewed my 95T and Marios 97 and in two days of driving they never once mentioned a noticeable gap in performance between the two except to say they liked the extra torque in the 3.2 that and they actually “…preferred the gear ratios in the 95”, “…the engine and the 5-speed is mated so well, it extracts so much from that engine but whichever you choose, you're going to love it, it’s such a brilliant car”. My car had about 50k on it at the time and Marios was a little over 100k I think. Take it for what its worth but to a couple of neutral outsiders who review cars professionally, Paul was a total Porsche guy, Todd was a Lotus lover, there wasnt enough difference between the two cars to talk much about.