I agree with RJ. Once you get one he can hook you up with a GTLW :biggrin: .Assuming both cars are in acceptable condition, I'd go for the 95 (I have one myself). I find the option to remove the top when the weather is just right is a terrific option to have at your disposal.
Also, the 5spd provides an even more sporty feel to an already incredible driving experience.
Good luck with your decision!
-RJ
Definitely get the manual transmission. However, I would prefer a '91-'94 coupe manual over a '95-'96 targa manual.