Do you know of any intake on the market that will actually add horsepower, or do they all just look cool and add to the sound of the car?
Most of the cone type replacements just look and sound cool. Their downfall is taking warm air from the engine compartment instead of cool, more dense, air from outside the car, like the OEM intake. As a result, they do not make more horsepower. They look and sound hot, but are not cool.
There are some intakes that do (or should) provide some horsepower gains.
Comptech claims that their
carbon fibre airbox adds eight horsepower. Note that it takes about three hours to install it. But what the heck, it is 8 hp!
Cantrell and Dali both sell an air intake that keeps the stock box (and, I believe, does not work with the Comptech box without some modifications). Science of Speed also sells the
Cantrell Air Intake Sysytem. Both are modelled on the instake that Honda used on its Lemans winning NSX. There has been considerable debate on whether it provides any horsepower gain. But knowing Honda's engineering excellence, they would not have gone to all of the effort if it did not provide some horsepower gains. I have one on my NSX and the sound is awe inspiring. Do I notice any gains? No, but the NSX engine is so highly tuned to begin with (and my butt is probably so badly calibrated
) that it would be hard to notice.
The issue of whether a drop-in OEM replacement filter produces any benefit or causes any engine maladies is also the subject of much debate. I use K&N drop-in OEM replacements on all my cars. On one, an Isuzu Trooper, it made a huge improvement, leading me to believe the OEM filter was very restrictive. On my NSX and my 3 series BMW I noticed no difference other than a bit more noise on the NSX.