FWIW I went from OEM Bridgestone RE010s on my /94 to the Conti Extreme Contact Sport about 1 year ago. I'm in the suburbs of the Motor City and our roads are so bad that I felt I needed something with a bit more compliance. While the Continental tires made the car infinitely more livable/comfortable than the stiff as a hockey puck sidewalls of the RE010s this clearly came at the expense of the handling. I don't push the car all that hard but the "confidence" and "fun" factors have markedly decreased. A bit hard to explain but I'll try. The RE010s had more stick and I never felt that I was approaching the limit (again, I don't push it too hard on public streets) -- very confidence inspiring. Not so much with the Contis -- the steering just doesn't talk to me the same way it did with the RE010s and the limit is perceptibly lower than on the RE010s. The car is just not as much fun anymore and doesn't handle as its maker intended which really is this car's raison d'etre. I'm not a knocking the Contis -- they serve their purpose -- better ride but somewhat degraded handling.
Now I wish I had bought an extra set of RE010s when they were available. Wonder if these can be sourced from Japan -- call/email to Marc Perez in order tomorrow.
Fortunately I have a minty set of 02+ wheels squirreled away and I suppose I can buy a set more performance oriented tires and then swap wheels as necessary. Of course this is going to lead to all manner of other trouble -- floor jack, torque wrench, other tools needed to do wheel swap...........LOL. However, I'll then presumably have the best of both worlds.
Best,
Jeff